I Switched From CHANEL Le Volume to Victoria Beckham’s Vast Lash: Here’s My Review

“Spice up your life”

— Spice Girls

I’ve been trying to find a new mascara for a while now. I’ve been using CHANEL Le Volume and honestly, I liked it — it gave the lift and definition I wanted without making my lashes feel crunchy. But I recently found out that CHANEL still tests its makeup on animals. And in this day and age, when there are so many cruelty-free alternatives, that was a clear dealbreaker for me.

The issue is that my eyes are very sensitive. Most mascaras either dry out my lashes or feel heavy and irritating. Which means I end up rubbing my eyes and looking like my teenage emo (but unintentionally this time). Not ideal.

So CHANEL stayed in my routine longer than it probably should have, simply because it didn’t upset my eyes. But then I kept seeing people on TikTok rave about Victoria Beckham Beauty, especially the Vast Lash Mascara. Everyone said it was expensive but (unfortunately for our wallets) genuinely worth it. Now that my CHANEL tube finally ran out, I decided it was time to try something new.

Just one more thing before we begin: I’m not a beauty influencer, and I’m not someone who wears a lot of makeup every day. Most of the time I’m not wearing makeup at all, and when I do, it’s usually just mascara and some foundation for dinner, events, or days when I want to feel a bit more put together. So this review is coming from someone who wants a mascara that looks good, feels comfortable, and doesn’t make my eyes want to fall off.

So, if you want to know how this mascara really performs beyond the TikTok hype, here’s my honest breakdown.

Let’s get into it and find out if Victoria Beckham Vast Lash mascara is worth it. But first, let’s dive into the brand real quick:

About Victoria Beckham Beauty

Victoria Beckham Beauty launched in 2019, after Victoria had already built her fashion brand (and long after we first knew her as Posh Spice from the Spice Girls). The beauty line focuses on high-performance formulas that are clean, cruelty-free, and comfortable to wear every day. The brand is known for keeping ingredients transparent and leaning into skincare benefits, which is something I pay attention to because of my sensitive eyes. The whole idea is elevated makeup that feels good on the skin, without heavy fragrances or irritation.

Yes, the products are definitely on the pricier side, but the general consensus (mostly from what I’ve read online) is that they’re well formulated and made to last. That’s what convinced me to start with Vast Lash before exploring anything else from the line — and, I’ll be honest, I’ve always had a soft spot for her.

When I was eight, my friends and I did a talent show performance to “Stop Right Now,” and I was Victoria. I was fully committed — I cut my hair into a bob and even dyed it just to look like her. So there’s definitely a little nostalgia at play here, too. Anyway… moving on.

So, What Does Vast Lash Promise to Do?

This mascara is meant to lift, lengthen, and define your lashes without clumping, smudging, or feeling heavy. It’s also supposed to stay in place throughout the day and still come off easily at night, which is great if you have sensitive eyes or just dislike that whole scrubbing your face like a raccoon situation.

The brush is slim and slightly curved, which helps catch those smaller lashes in the corners (the ones most mascaras pretend don’t exist). The overall effect it aims for is not dramatic or “false lash” volume — more of a clean, separated, awake look.

… Does It Actually Deliver?

One coat of the Vast Lash Mascara

And now for the moment you’ve been waiting for. Does it actually deliver on its promise?

In my opinion, yes. It does.

When I first tried it, I noticed right away that it separates the lashes really well. No clumping, no smudging. It gives a natural, defined look without being dramatic. I was used to the more dramatic effect of the CHANEL mascara, so my first thought was, okay, this is more subtle than what I normally wear.

Then I added a second layer, and that did it. It gave more volume and a bit more of that “done” look, but still without clumping. For reference, I don’t have very long lashes, so for me this was a really nice balance.

The part I was most worried about was irritation or heaviness, and that didn’t happen. It feels lightweight — like I wasn’t wearing mascara — and I didn’t have the urge to rub my eyes throughout the day.

As for how it lasts: I put it on and went for a champagne and oyster lunch (I like to think Victoria would be very proud of me). I came home, and it still looked the same. Later, I fell asleep with my makeup on because I had too much champagne (yes, I know, you’re not supposed to, but here we are), and when I woke up, it was still in place. No smudging. No flaking. No under-eye situation.

When I washed it off, it came off easily with warm water. No rubbing, no tugging, no leftover bits stuck in the lashes. This was definitely not the case with the CHANEL mascara.

So yes, it does what it claims to do.

Pros & Cons

Now let’s get into the pros and cons. I always find this part the most helpful because it just lays things out clearly. Nothing dramatic, just what it does well and where it might fall short depending on what you’re looking for.

Pros

• Separates lashes really well

• You can build it from one coat (very natural) to two coats (more defined)

• Very lightweight feel on the eyes, no irritation

• Stays in place throughout the day (even through champagne naps)

• Comes off easily with warm water, no rubbing or tugging

• Contains slightly more product than CHANEL Le Volume (0.22 fl oz vs 0.21 oz)

• Cruelty-free (not tested on animals)

Cons

• One coat is quite natural (if you want instant volume, you'll need at least two)

• It’s on the pricier side

• The tube itself is quite large for a mascara

• The wand feels heavier in the hand compared to the CHANEL one, which takes some getting used to

• If you prefer a bold, dramatic lash look every day, this may feel too subtle

The Verdict

In my opinion, both mascaras are really nice. If you prefer a dramatic, “wow” lash look from the first coat, then the CHANEL one does give that more immediately. But to be fair, that’s not what the Vast Lash mascara claims to do, so I don’t think it’s a direct comparison. The Victoria Beckham mascara is meant to look more natural to start, and it does.

What really stands out to me is the comfort. Vast Lash doesn’t irritate my eyes at all, and it feels incredibly lightweight, like I’m not wearing mascara. It also comes off very easily with warm water, and it genuinely doesn’t smudge, flake, or move throughout the day. Everything it says it will do, it actually does.

For me, I’m happy I made the switch. I don’t mind adding an extra coat for more volume, and I prefer knowing I’m using a cruelty-free option. The small difference in effect is worth it to me. So if you want something comfortable, easy, buildable, and cruelty-free, I can honestly recommend this.

I hope this review gave you some clarity and answered a few of the questions you might have had. If there’s anything else you’re wondering, feel free to reach out — I’m happy to help.

More Fashion & Beauty Essentials & Tips

← All Fashion & Beauty